July 31, 2017
Codemanship Code Craft "Driving Test" - Code Quality CriteraMuch pondering today about the code quality standards that should be applied in the Codemanship Code Craft Driving Test we'll be trialling at the end of the summer.
Since it's a test, I think it's fair to apply more rigorous and unyielding standards, provided that these are laid out unambiguously in advanced.
We can divide it up into 7 key areas, with some slightly different criteria for test code to allow for more verbose method names and a bit more code duplication:
1. It Works
* Your solution passes all of the customer tests we'll give you
* Your solution also survives a more exhaustive suite of tests to hunt for any lurking bugs
2. It's Readable
* The Conceptual Correlation between your code and the requirements is > 80%
* Non of your identifiers contain > 20 characters (except for test method names)
* No line of your code contains > 100 characters
3. It's Low in Duplication
* A check using Simian will reveal no more than 15% code duplication (We'll give you the precise Simian options so you can check for yourself)
4. It's Made of Simple Parts
* No method will contain > 10 LOC
* No method will have > 2 branches
* No method will have > 3 parameters
* No method will have Boolean parameters
* No class will have > 6 methods
5. It's Made of Swappable Parts
* Excluding in your tests, all dependencies on other classes in your solution will be swappable by dependency injection. Use of DI frameworks will also be forbidden. (Dependency Inversion)
* No non-test class will invoke any method on an instance of another class in the solution that can't be easily extended or swapped (e.g., in C#, only methods on interfaces or virtual methods can be invoked)
6. The Parts Are Loosely Coupled
* No class will depend on > 3 other classes in your solution
* No method will exhibit Feature Envy (when a method of one class uses more than one method of another) for other classes in your solution (Tell, Don't Ask)
* No class or interface will expose features to another class that it doesn't use (Interface Segregation)
* No class will invoke methods on solution classes which are not direct collaborators (i.e., fields or parameters) (Law of Demeter)
7. Test Code Quality
* No unit test will make more than one assertion (or mock object equivalent)
* There will be exactly one unit test method per requirements rule, the name of the test will clearly describe the rule
* All of the unit tests will pass without any external dependencies
* There will be a maximum of 10% integration test code, packaged separately
* The tests will run in < 10 seconds
* Tests will contain < 25% code duplication
Now, even though there's quite a lot of meat on these bones, these criteria may change, of course. But probably not much.
In the trial, I'll be verifying many of them by hand. This will give ma chance to validate them and iron out any conceptual kinks.
The long-term intention is that most - if not all - of these checks will be automated. Initially, I'm working on doing that in C# for the .NET developer community.
The code quality criteria will form half the score for the driving test. To pass it, you'll also need to demonstrate your practices and habits, and explain why you're doing them, so we can evaluate how much insight you have into code craft and the reasons for it. This will be done by recording a 30-minute screencast at some point during the test that we can assess.
More news soon.
Posted 7 months, 1 day ago on July 31, 2017